Comments

Translation = if we deem something as an emergency, we will censor again.

It makes me sad that content creators have to use code words to speak in America or else just self censor so their videos aren’t removed or demonetized

Classic example of someone who says a lot without saying anything.

He's a politician. He said so many words but didn't really say anything. What a waste of time

Politician answers. Noice!😂

"Youtube stands for free speech?", are you kidding me? This is like calling Netanyahu a man of peace....

Corpo speak is a masterclass in how to make nothing burgers

homie just gave the obama handshake to chamanth and a normal handshake to everyone else

15:06 Mohan: Let me finish JCal: Get to the point

Glad Jason asks probing/pushy questions to make the discussion more interesting. Good job Jason!

I would rate Mohan's interview the last of this years All-in 2025 summit interviews. Great questions were asked and not a single direct answer. Most censored platform today compared to others based on my 10 years on this platform.

He did not answer the questions regarding censorship. He only used word salad to distract like cheap politicians.

He didn’t apologize or commit to not censoring speech again

Fire him as Ceo. he is a heavy heavy cheater and not answering any question.

Thank you All-inBesties. This clearly shows that the major source of problems at YouTube is this mediocre executive . He also loves to say “…but many are..” Yet he never would say what his values are at YouTube and how they have standards that they will stand behind.

What a politician. True Indian.

This episode is an amazing piece of fiction, selective amnesia, and a masterful example of the art of deflection.

Neal Mohan dodged the question about censorship during covid, As a content platform, he has no business censoring any information because it should be left up to the viewer to decide whether they like the content or not. It is sickening, that content platforms take on the role of the "Ministry of Truth", and take on one side of the narrative while suppressing the other side.

youtube used to be a haven for independent journalists and today it seems washed out with mainstream. i hate that my algorithms will always suggest mainstream channels even if i only sub to the small guys

No matter what anyone says, on Youtube you do find all kinds of voices.

This guys speaks in riddles. Just be bloody honest.

Would have expected a lot more from the YouTube CEO. Disappointing interview (versus the other great ones from AllIn)

The worst thing that could have happened to YouTube.Feel bad for people who have to work under him.Innovation has completely fallen off the cliff. The only thing he can think of is shoving more Ads down people’s throats.

45 55 split seems greedy asf that's insane

This guy is a tool. All his answers were something you hear from a fake politician.

No pushback or tough question from chamath. This guy know he's guilty of all the bad stuff people complain about. He never answer direct questions. This fool is responsible for all the stupid taylor swift videos in my feed.

So he’s why Youtube is Adtube now

Youtube has a platform. They don't create superstars. Superstars create themselves. Youtube takes no risk it's just a platform. They pay a fractional part post their own earning. The profit comes from a highly replicable model for them. Constant expanse of infrastructure and using AI well to give a decent ROI for advertisers.

After this video I decided to try Rumble.

Neal is awesome! I’ve heard him speak on several creators’ channels, and he always shares great advice. He’s knowledgeable, down-to-earth, and genuinely cool.

Welcome to censorship land! what a shitty interview 😂 oh sorry, google is a sponsor

The biggest force for censorship. Reinstate Alex Jones. COVID was made in a lab.

Does he even understand what an open platform is; he just said they have to control based on the environment? These guys have too much power in their hands and control and moderate in a manner they can influence outcomes…

Word salad 🥗 lost respect for him and YouTube

He makes Susan look like a competent CEO

RESIGN and eat beef paajeet

RESIGN and eat beef

And everyone complains about Apple taking 30%.

Monopoly squandering at it's finest.

He's a coward, a liar, and a tyrant.

It would be funny if this video got censored

RESIGN scammer

RESIGN and enjoy Red fort

70,000,000,000 paid out to 3,000,000 partners, That's on avg $23k a creator over three years. Basically YouTube alone isn't enough to live off. Which is sad, as content will continue to be bias by ad buyers.

He doesnt answer the questions. Dont waste your time with this one

Typical rose-up-the-corporate-ladder kind of guy. Very dishonest.

Youtube is the greatest platform

eat beef and RESIGN paajeet

RESIGN paajeet cow

this guy sucks

ATÁ !!! Agora entendi,esse CEO quer transformar o youtube em televisão FOCADA em ESPORTES e NOTÍCIAS DA GRANDE MÍDIA,e o resto de nós criadores que se lasquem com as quedas GIGANTESCAS de visualizações e da renda financeira.

Very very scary

YouTube is the Gutenberg Press

Duck and doge. Duck and doge.

Not a good platform if he is ok to censor. Not a fan.

what a word salad! also what an un-impressive CEO of such an important company.

you tube will blare the loudest ads when it detects non interaction(to check if your asleep) then if you dont wake or interact, they will play tens of minutes of ads and cha ching! They can tell the advertisers, wow look how many full views....pay up! When really they are just extracting cash. The companies whose ads are shown during this times are small to mid size companies, to unsophisticated to know they are being robbed, and to broke to do anything about it if they could. No company will fall harder than alphabet.......soon.

Wow..jason start by asking that question..:)

YT lucky there isnt a better platform YET.

Send YouTube off to India. Strip Youtube of it's USA corporate charter. Break the monopoly and allow Americans to start fresh. We don't need them.

He is not honest

Wow!! Chamath, what a brilliant question around the connective tissue around the social zeitgeist!

If you are just a platform to help advertisers get to their targetted audience, then the platform cannot be the judge for censorship unless on grounds of being visually or verbally abusive. Not based on opinion.

"You are betting on you self"... till we BLOCK you😂

What could this man have any knowledge of when it comes to the future of creators when he’s destroying so many. A ludicrous individual I hope he’s sacked soon or YouTube is quite literally gonna be taken to court over all of this fraudulent AI advertising.

RESIGN and eat beef steaks

get the ads out

Translation: All I care about is the bottom line.

The worst yet an average CEO that does NOT take responsibility with the children's and the minors privacy and safety morals for the bots sending out and spamming out comments that are ai generated, yet the mods don't do their job, because it's all AI made, no actual employee can atleast take care of this situation.

Mohan should go work at macdonald. At least he would do something actually useful.

So what did he say exactly? The guys are being polite and listening while he rambles on

This guys answers all the questions about demonetization and freedom of speech like a fucking politician. All I hard was a word salad. I wish Jcal and David Sacks would have pushed harder.

So companies pay them to place ads and then consumers can pay not to watch those ads. How does that math work? Also, he totally dodged answering the Q Sacks asked about censorship

We support free speech because we didnt censor/demonitize everyone. He's basically saying they won't have the backbone to do the right thing and bend to whomever puts pressure. Should have pushed him on why Tulsi Gabbard's AIP segment was blocked.

RESIGN Haguman

His babbling speech reflects his leadership. Incoherent and clueless

Had to stop Midway through. Can't take any more of this spin merchant

Neal Mohan is chill af

Appreciate the gentleman coming on and answering questions. The platform is convenient. That being said, a really bad taste in lots of people's mouth from kowtowing to politicians and pharma (either side).

Fire this man now!

NEAL MOHAN WHY DID YOU BAN ENDERMAN FROM YOUTUBE HE DIDN'T UPLOAD ANY INAPPROPRIATE VIDEOS HE ALWAYS UPLOADS EDUCATIONAL VIDEOS AND HE'S MY NOSTALGIC TECH CHANNEL YOU BETTER STOP USING AI 🤬😡🔥🖕

He’s full of BS, they where part of the problem during covid

The algorithms tend to put people into bubbles. So when you want to know why people on the extremes are in such a bubble...the algorithms that generate their feed definitely contributes

YouTube shorts with no option to turn off, so not google

YouTube is being critiqued for too much Free Speech? Seriously?!? Any rationale assessment of how YouTube handled the COVID debacle, and continues to handle debate on other hot topics (e.g. the Trans issue) would confirm that it’s still censoring and stifling free speech.

Be glad for hearing straight from the horse’s mouth.

wow he looks lazy from lack of competition

Adsense is literally what has made YouTube beat meta and twitter on video

Stop censoring creators Neal

Neal and David Baszuski would be good friends.

鼻の横に出来物があって不細工ですね

I had an almost 1500 subscriber but I lost it for music copyright. So I created my background music. But, it’s sad that now many music are surfacing that doesn’t seem to nonrestrictive. I used the music they used but they weren’t banned. It should be that they charge for copyright right, then charge. Don’t automatically warn, or ban. If there is a charge for using it then charge. Obviously, someone owns it and there’s a fee for using it. But don’t ban and remove an account. What Happened to those that subscribers? Sold to someone? Who’s collecting the money?

I regret all times when i hated on Susan. This guy is the epitome of worst that could happen.

He’s a scammer, the advertising program he’s running don’t do it they keep the money you earn and won’t let you withdraw it. I did the work but their keeping not only the wages I earned but also the money I added to the account . It’s all a scam to get peoples money with no way to withdraw

making free features premium , greed is your genius .

He doesn’t give a shit about anything he is saying. I have been reporting channels of abuse and harassment and bullying for years and he has done shit. As long as the money keeps coming in he has no values

I want to know why YouTube is deceptive with advertising and more. Has AI taken the helm? The adds skip and time count down is misleading. YouTube also purposely shuts my internet down bumps me off of it not always but when i skip commercials a few times have to reconnect. Sometimes i yell at the channel on my roku tv saying AI is evil it immediately stops and listens for some back ground sound. I say stop listening YouTube and it goes back to the program i had been watching. Messed up. Can you confirm that its YouTube or the network provider. Thank you.

If he runs for president, he would run the nation like 1984's Big Brother.

that dude knows how to talk a lot and say nothing! Great job buddy !

Jason is shitty and rude to people I don't understand the joking attitude, he did it to the Solana guy too

❤ Sacks directness.

The real world is here . Anyone can experience it and compare!

@11:20 Excellent question.

A million times…I and I and I….I said, I did, I tell, it’s me, me and me…all about me….

Thank you for sharing this!

27:46 tokenized videos built on eth

I get the grossest YouTube commercials, I complain to them often, but they keep showing them. Plus, even though I have subscriptions, the algorithm is such that I get mostly outdated programs, or they send me stuff that I’m not interested in.

Pricing like ESPN.

Im about to cancel my youtube premium. I purchased so i didnt have to listen to ads. Now creators read multiple ads through out there videos and its just annoying. Why pay for premium if im still listening and watching ads?!?

He's a damn liar. They are still censoring heavily, just not as heavily as before.

I love YouTube premium. I understand the reason why some advertisers don’t want their ads randomly showing up on videos that they don’t agree with-and this is the reason why YouTube has a monetization policy. However if I’m paying my own money for YouTube premium, I want my dollars supporting the creators I enjoy. The allocation of that money should not be based on the ad model.

JCal has balls. I admire that

What a waste of time. Lots of words but nothing said. These guys are the kings of sensorship. Don't usually agree with Jason but at least he asked a few good relevant questions not just stoking his ego like the others.

Completely skirted around the Covid censorship of videos trying to infer comments only. This was not the case. Essentially anything questioning masks, origins, vaccines was shadow banned immediately across the board (YouTube, Meta, Google, Twitter). Sounds like they have no regret, and only playing "nice" for Trump and if Democrats win the next election I fully expect their campaign of censorship to pick up right where they left off.

I have never been paid😂 I am on my second year😂

🇩🇪 🇻🇦

If he retires I bet his successor will be worse, Either that or he never retires

11:47

@Neal Mohan why is YouTube censoring and closing down steamers that are against the IRCG and current Iranian regime and use lies to justify the close down? You maybe have employees supporting IRGC and current regime of Iran in the probing teams that work to take down critics of the current Iranian regime by order from it. The U.S. government designated Iran's Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) as a Foreign Terrorist Organization (FTO) on April 15, 2019. The Iranian regime, specifically the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) and its Quds Force, is widely designated as a terrorist entity by multiple nations and bodies, including the US, EU, Canada, Australia, and Saudi Arabia. Goldi Ghamari streaming on YouTube was closed down with showing gun/ fire arm, but there was no one in the streaming. She appealed and YouTube answered that the reason is fire arms, but there were none. She was also blocked from life streaming. It would be sad that people working at YouTube working for Iran to block and censor YouTubers that have live-streaming about for example Iran and what’s happening there.

This guy is total politician, no wonder folks are facing passive aggressive issues from YouTube so regularly.

All fof

Are we... screwed?

Yeah whatever works for you like thanks Neil super insightful the guys basically admitting the big fish swim away because is too fat but instead of changing it just goes cool. Good for them man. If your top creators are their own ads you’re not running a platform you’re running a launchpad and that’s fine if you’re honest about it but don’t act like it’s all entrepreneurial freedom when the little guys are paying the premium for that dream.

That’s rude buried under policy change from 2009 to 2010 when they were still figuring out monetisation but screw that you should’ve been grandfathered in GoPro. Listen to you. Why won’t let’s see if I can dig up some help on the recovery process. No bullshit this time.

People used to be good because they were afraid to go to hell, i guess nobody is scared of hell anymore. Untill you are there.

Please neal fix youtube circumvention policy, my favourite channels are deleted 😢 without any strong reasons 😖

Wow. He may be a product genius but overall I would say that is very weak sauce. He easily wins the dodge award this year for not answering very direct questions. One can only assume he/they learned nothing from their Covid censorship experience and would do, and maybe are, the same thing again. Quite the hubris. I am a short.

Just don’t let it bounce back on you, I’m on your side Seb.

I was hoping this was the time where Jason learns how to say monetize. 😢

What are the latest updates on Nano technologies? How soon will we see the nano-fabricator' a device that will allow us to assemble just about anything, atom by atom; including itself? IT COULD MEAN THE END OF SCARCITY ITSELF.

Did he say “bake” their ads in? The Tuckers & Meghans? @4:14 what does this mean?

I am in minute 21 and there is no A.I. 😅

Windsock

???????

What about creators that come to the platform with 3decades of experience in cinematography whose personal business has been rendered useless?

125m Premium subs.

Probably the best episode of this season

Is he Made ceo for saving up the asses of person like sandesh gawande and fam and alike in the USA. And I think such people are here only monitoring what truthful facts I’m sharing against such people

take 45 percent and have no money for shoelaces. thats commitment, hihi.